Tuesday, May 01, 2007

April Musings

The call of Varanasi has been strident at times, and a low persistent one at others. This piece will do no justice and the incomplete, unfinished sense will prevail. The sense is the same for every seeker, unfinished incompleteness that the city fulfils briefly. It is a resting place, a base camp of sorts for an onward journey. I recently visited a fabulous exhibition of the paintings of Yashwant Shirwadkar at Jahangir Art Gallery. The theme was ‘Benaras’ and the pull became strident once more. Shirwadkar spends a month on the river and captures the ghats at different times of the day. He photographs, makes sketches and goes back year after year for more.

The city, the visitors to the ghats, the look of the ghats changes, and the artist brings back his current impressions and paints differently each time. My work as a researcher is not unlike that of artist Shirwadkar, and I tell stories of what I see and share this with my clients, building a kaleidoscopic picture or a mosaic based on discussions with the consumers I speak with. A friend gifted me a wonderful CD called ‘Soundwalk’ an audio guide to the first time traveler to Varanasi.

I heard the call with my first visit in 1999. It was a most fortuitous occurrence, a research that didn’t happen due to some unforeseen circumstances. And I got introduced to the river and the city like a tourist. It was a deep-dive into a heady, heavy, overwhelmed feeling. It was a medley, a sense of spiritualism, mixed-up mythology and history, my own self and my destiny, and above all a great curiosity to get under the skin of the city and of its people.

Varanasi is eternal and ephermal all at the same time. It is made up of evolved spiritualism and mysticism as it is an intensely physical experience that assails every sense. Age-old educational institutions and trading institutions juxtaposed, traditional handicrafts with modern-day multipliers, Varanasi is as much about life’s endings as it is about beginnings. It is a city where black and white doesn’t blur into a gray.

I came here first to study the banal and the very ‘this worldly’. It was a study of consumers in the context of their oral care habits, by exposing them to product formats and concepts. In talking with these housewives, their refinement, education, openness of mind, ability to think and to articulate, came as a big surprise. These women might not have traveled much in physical terms, but they were exposed to thoughts and ideas. There was in them a maturity, the wisdom and an ability to articulate, that a poet might attribute to the holy polluted water that flows and the muggy air over the city.

The most recent visit took place 6 months ago. It was a little more broad-based this time. I was there to study girls between the ages of 13 and 24; to understand their routine, the high points, pain points and their drivers. I spoke with some ‘experts’ – a headmistress of a junior college and a dressmaker. Studying changes in their families, their relationships, and changes around them helped me get a little under their skin.

The young girls appear to have the strong context for the modern that sits comfortably with the traditional. They are aware, aspiring, ambitious, and want to improve their lot and to live an ‘achchi zindag, a good life’. This ‘good life’ means happiness for their parents and family, being financially independent, and being in a comfortable marriage. Love and romance are usually experienced under wraps, covertly through friends’ experiences, most of which are not happy. I heard tales of experimentation, making mistakes, feeling sorry for oneself, feeling misunderstood, guilty, and sadness, a sense of feeling ‘used’, and a huge emotional drain of keeping everyone in the family in the dark.

The women in Varanasi are more educated, and they read and write much more their counterparts in other cities. They are more comfortable with expression, using poetry and keeping a daily diary. The 13 – 16 year olds enjoy traditional arts as much as they enjoy using Paint on the computer. There is a higher emotional sensitivity and a heightened sense of perceptiveness in the 19 – 24 year old. This leads to greater dialogue and expression. They are not afraid of expressing, and find avenues to experience and to feel fulfilled.

The dressmaker I spoke with chose to move back to Varanasi and live with her parents and maintain a long-distance marriage. Her daughter who is 11 converses with me in English, attired in a neat and smart skirt and blouse. The tailor has a small workshop at home and she needs to spend time looking at patterns on TV. She walks down the lane that leads to Dasashwamedh Ghat browsing through the clothes and mannequins, absorbing styles and patterns. Her clientele makes specific demands and clothes have to have tighter fits, innovative backs, interesting embroidery and cuts and blouses with more daring necklines. Everyone is moving ahead and on the treadmill of being modern and with the times.

The city is changing at a blurring pace. Young girls today are training themselves for a career. According to the headmistress I spoke with, parents support their children’s ambitions. Curricular and co-curricular experiences are about giving the young girl an edge to help her succeed anywhere. The accent is on the flowering of individual talents, not restricted to academic achievements alone. Coaching classes are an enabler for socialization, celebrating birthday parties and picnics, as they are for exploring fashion and food, forging friendships, building confidence and experiencing dreams and life.
Mass media is the great leveler of experiences, and the male head of the household is no longer the ubiquitous patriarch. In the present-day knowledge economy, power and control come from being well-informed, in keeping with the times.

Varanasi as nucleus and magnet has enabled the flourishing of a confluence of cultures, attracting travelers from different worlds, with their unique and multifarious needs. It is both an enabler to settle as much as a launch-pad to move on, in real and in metaphysical terms. A unique city unlike another and this researcher’s favourite puzzle!

Deepa Soman
May 1, 2007

Labels:

Saturday, September 02, 2006

N-Light: Re-crafting the Concept: Independence Day

Saturday, August 19, 2006

Re-crafting the Concept: Independence Day

The eve of 14th August is the heralding of another new year of Indian "independence". Ask an average Indian of what "independence day" means and the answers will centre around the theme, "freedom from the rule of the British" and the becoming of an independent, free democracy

The symbols that have been imprinted on our collective memory would vary by the generation a person belongs to. However the common symbols that would emerge are the unfurled tricolour, New Delhi, Red Fort, the Independence Day floats, the president's address to the nation on the eve of Independence Day, the Prime Minister's speech on Independence Day, flag hoisting in schools, colleges, housing colonies, marigold petals people in white, sweets distributed to children, "patriotic" films on TV, "Gandhi", "1947", "Bhagat Singh", "The Legend of Bhagat Singh", and other popular entertainment fare

A long weekend to the urban office goer could mean "getting away from the city", relaxing, holidaying. The thought, the reason, sentiment is scarcely top of mind for the full day of the 15th of August. Decade after decade going farther away from 1947 has meant holding on to some external symbols of Independence. The emotion is quite entirely different for a person who was 12 in 1947 to the person who turned 12 in 2004, even if a part of the same family.
It is both difficult, and impractical to expect an honest mirroring of the emotions, particularly patriotic zeal in keeping with the passions of 1947. The same can be said of victories in sports where, while there will be pride at the winning of the 1983 Prudential Cup, today's twelve year old will scarcely feel that passion the boy of 12 felt in 1983.

In the context of Independence, the concept of "patriotic zeal" in a growing global economy when the British no longer evoke any feelings of hatred, anger, of a person wronged almost seem politically incorrect and passé.

So while the signs and symbols of Independence Day are all intact, they are hollow without the marrow of emotion and passion to keep them relevant and current. The practice of Independence Day is presently a mere ritual, a ceremony without the necessary "living" of the value of Independence Day. And this is bound to happen for "Independence from the British" despite what the history books say, is irrelevant to today's 12 year old

At an individual level, some families may keep the emotion alive by talking and sharing of independence, with stories of sacrifice and denial, bravery and resistance. The elation of the victory, of attaining Independence was marred with the torturous journey of Partition, the pain, the aftermath and the losses. So it was never pure joy and celebration, as the template for the victory was made of pain and a steep price paid for freedom

The challenge of the new millennium is to keep alive the concept and the powerful symbol of "independence" by creating a current and wider relevance for the larger than life symbol, a part of the Indian ethnic identity, the single largest idea of the century for India. The challenge is to find the next big idea for the new millennium, an idea that builds and stands on the shoulders of Indian Independence of 1947 that can correct the dilution of the emotions that have to sustain the life force in the symbol

The next big idea can be the re-crafting of the concept of Independence, by shifting the present locus of "freedom from" to connote a relevant problem or issue that needs rectification. A freedom from all that ails our society, state, community, and individual, that will replace the idea of the passé "freedom from the British" thought. By freeing "Independence" from "British", we have our big idea, always current. The idea of independence once it is freed from the binds of "from the British", can soar and make connections with each problem we wish to rid ourselves of.

The list of ills to rid ourselves of, can be a mile long, freedom from corruption, freedom from hunger, freedom from unemployment, freedom from thirst, freedom from darkness, freedom from illiteracy, freedom from AIDS, freedom from pollution, freedom from poor sanitation, freedom from dirt, freedom from crime, freedom from fear... And we have only just begun making our list. At an individual level, "freedom" can translate into many of the areas that apply to the state. The day to adopt the beginning of this novel quest for freedom can be on "independence day", the commencement period, the milestone for measuring "progress"

It is proposed that this be adopted as a pilot at a micro level, at individual, school, community, village level, and to demonstrate how the targeted change materialized. Rather than a promise made by someone extraneous, it is for each individual to decide what that "from" would be against with the war for independence would be waged. Such experiments can be scaled up and adopted in urban and rural communities and it has the potential to become a district, state and national agenda.

The immediate benefit from adopting this proposal to re-craft the concept of Independence Day is the focused application of all energies to a tangible objective or goal so that individuals can practice a higher order sense of responsibility.

An extreme version of this commitment is compulsory military conscription as practiced in Israel. What is being proposed is a kind of "social conscription" for perpetuity. The "for" and the enemy within will be identified and the objective and program will be selected.

How is this concept different from the clichéd slogans and promises of politicians? It is different because it engages the entire society, and provides a focal point with a strong symbolism that already exists. Further, there will be an annual commitment to map progress, celebrate victories big and small against set tasks, and create the buzz to inspire and energize more to adopt the new recrafted concept of Independence Day.

Perhaps in a ten year time period, the child of 12 who would have turned 22 will have an India closer to the ideal that was envisaged by the freedom fighters who fought for Indian Independence from the British and their sacrifice would not be in vain. There would be an action oriented celebration of "independence" and the special day would be one for action coupled with contemplation to replace today's listless, confused Independence Day celebrations

Deepa Soman
10th February 2005